It's kind of amazing, when I first found this site, the leaf was a concept car, and the only electric was the Tesla. It's truly amazing how far it's come in the past few months
A Tale of Two Electric Vehicles Getting Made
December is the month that EV enthusiasts have been waiting for. The Chevy Volt is rolling off production lines at G.M.’s Detroit-Hamtramck facility, and the first Nissan LEAF will be delivered tomorrow in San Francisco. As we anticipate the reports coming from new EV owners, we're also waiting to see if the next wave of automakers—from Fisker and Coda to Smart and Mitsubishi—execute their plans with as much exuberance and professionalism as G.M. and Nissan.
That’s what makes Ford’s announcement this week about the first production versions of the Transit Connect Electric delivery van seem, well, a bit sad. Check out the two videos below—one of the Chevy Volt getting made, and one of the Ford Transit Connect EV being assembled. The contrast between the two shows just how far and fast the electric car movement has moved in recent years.
The making of the first Ford Transit Connect Electric delivery vans in the U.S.
Production of the Chevy Volt.
Okay, it’s not really a fair comparison. The Connect Electric is more of a quick demonstration project for Ford, as they work toward release of their more serious EV contender: Ford Focus Electric.
The Transit Connect Electric is hand made from gliders that arrive in Michigan. The electric drive system then is installed by A.M. General, the company best known for building military humvees and for creating the Hummer line. For the foreseeable future, the $57,400 Transit Connect Electric will go strictly fleet customers, such as A.T.&T and New York Power Authority and Southern California Edison. Even at full production, scheduled for April 2011, Ford will only produce 600 to 700 vehicles per year.
Using EVs in fleets makes a ton of sense, and the Transit Connect Electric looks like a great vehicle. I had a chance to drive one at the Chicago Auto Show in February, and it offered a nice ride in a compelling package. Its 28 kilowatt-hour provides about 80 miles of range—just right for many local delivery routes.
But the low-volume by-hand process of assembly, at least at this stage, reveals that the Ford Transit Connect Electric is more experimental than a serious production vehicle. Moreover, it shows how the field of upcoming EVs is very uneven. The Chevy Volt and Nissan LEAF have now set a new higher standard for every other automaker—big and small—to follow.
Car companies, take note: From this point forward, merely producing an EV is no longer enough to earn public respect. It has to be a vehicle that is made with the same level of commitment and resources as any other car on the road.
Comments
· lektrcninja · 1 year ago
· lektrcninja · 1 year ago
It's kind of amazing, when I first found this site, the leaf was a concept car, and the only electric was the Tesla. It's truly amazing how far it's come in the past few months
· EtechTim (not verified) · 43 weeks ago
Hi Brad,
It is an error to compare these two videos and treat that as a basis for comparison of the commitment of the car companies involved. The data is incomplete. When the article says "Ok, its not really a fair comparison" now, that is correct - but buried below the fold.
Not shown in the video, Ford has a robot staffed sparks flying assembly plant for Transit Connect vans - In Turkey. Those bodies are repurposed with both gasoline and battery drive trains for a smaller market of city delivery trucks. You could say it is a more 'green' car for using what is already there. Also, bravely, actual components of the Magna drivetrain are shown in detail. The US built TC bodies come out after 2012. The components of the Transit Connect drive system have a more proven heritage on the road. The construction process shown is similar to GM convertibles in the 1980's where the cars were made, then rolled to a second small shop to have the roofs removed and be made into convertibles.
The Volt is a very flashy video which actually shows little detail. You don't see the workings, the parts, the faces. But it is a good show for the taxpayers who funded it. An automated assembly line does not show the people who programmed the equipment and calculated the strength of every weld, its placement and timing. It is an error to compare these two videos and treat that as a comparison of commitment of the car companies involved. The data is incomplete.
Turning out a column regularly requires certain "made -ya - look" techniques employed here. Neither video should be construed as an indicator of the quality of the resulting vehicle and should be treated as a comparison between an apple slice and orange juice. Each a portion of what cannot be directly compared.
Tim Greenwood
Television Producer, ATAS
Instructor, NYFA
Add comment
All Discussions
States Consider Taxing Electric Cars to Make Up For Lost Gas Tax Revenue
Blog Post · 50 comments
Zach McDonald says:
Politicians in at least three states are reportedly considering the creation of plug-in car taxes. The new fees would...
Tesla Model S Range Exceeds Even Tesla's Expecations
Tesla Model S Article · 7 comments
Eric Loveday says:
According to Tesla Motors, the 85-kWh version of the Model S is expected to achieve 250-350 miles of range during...
Nissan's Fourth Electric Vehicle to be PIVO-Inspired Urban Commuter
Article · 12 comments
Brad Berman says:
Reports suggest that Nissan's fourth electric-only automobile will be a funky high-tech PIVO-inspired urban commuter...
Canada's First DC Quick-Charge Station is Now Operational
Article · 8 comments
Eric Loveday says:
Mitsubishi of Canada moved a step or two closer to more convenient charging of its electric i hatchback with the...
Does EV Quick-Charging By the Minute Make Sense?
Nissan LEAF Article · 20 comments
Brad Berman says:
When drivers of gas-powered cars fill up at the gas station, they know they are paying a certain price for a clear and...
Wanted: Fair Costs for Electric Car Home Charger Installations
Chevy Volt Article · 43 comments
Josie Garthwaite says:
As a new generation of plug-in vehicles rolls off the assembly line, a new cadre of consumers has entered the market...
Mitsubishi Unveils PX-MiEV II Plug-in Hybrid Crossover SUV
Mitsubishi PX-MiEV Article · 9 comments
Eric Loveday says:
Mitsubishi will officially unveil its near-production-ready plug-in hybrid PX-MiEV II crossover at this month's 2011...
Projected EPA Range Ratings Emerge for All Versions of Tesla Model S
Tesla Model S Article · 6 comments
Eric Loveday says:
Accounting for all three variations in battery capacity, Motor Trend claims the 2012 Tesla Model S will likely earn an...
Ford Focus Electric Rollout Continues to Crawl
Ford Focus Electric Article · 17 comments
Brad Berman says:
I ran into a friend in Los Angeles this week who called Ford’s dealership in Santa Monica—a red hot hotspot for EV...
Appears the Volt assembly line is a bit more automated than the Ford Transit Connect Electric. :-) For Ford to make hay over the Transit Connect Electric is pathetic. It would be as if Chevrolet were claiming some sort of victory with the AMP built electric Equinox.
http://www.ampelectricvehicles.com/equinox.aspx