All-Electric Nissan LEAF Rear-Ends Bus

By Brad Berman · February 06, 2012

Nissan LEAF bus accident

A Nissan LEAF rear-ended a school bus and, despite being heavily damaged, the LEAF shows us that plug-in vehicles can be safe.

The federal investigation into safety concerns related to the Chevy Volt were closed last month, and hopefully will continue to recede in the rear-view mirror. As opposed to the simulated tests conducted on the Volt, real-world accidents involving plug-in cars will begin to create a set of data points about EV safety.

Just last week, Oregon's Yamhill Valley News-Register reported that a 2011 Nissan LEAF collided with a Yamhill-Carlton school bus in the early morning hours of Jan. 31. Fortunately, the school bus was empty and the driver of the LEAF, Robert Hill, suffered only minor injuries.

Oregon State Police were called to the scene and cited Hill for careless driving. It's believed that Hill rear-ended the bus, which was stopped waiting to turn left after traffic cleared.

State troopers report that the LEAF's front and side airbags deployed. Hill was treated for his injuries at the scene. Meanwhile, the driver of the bus escaped injury.

Though Gaston Rural Fire District was on the scene, the heavily damaged Nissan LEAF did not ignite—providing at least one example of a crashed electric vehicle showing zero signs of possible fire. There are nearly 20,000 new plug-in cars on US roads, and unfortunately some of them will be in accidents. Each case will teach us something—and ultimately, the aggregate data from all EV-related accidents will create a sober and realistic accounting of the relative fire safety of an electric car versus vehicles fueled by gasoline or diesel.

Comments

· Andreas (not verified) · 1 year ago

Pretty unsafe school bus...
you can easily see, that the front bumper (and the underlying structure) did not take any energy out of the crash due to the high unprotected rear end of the school bus. In Europe all trucks have to have protection bars for this kind of crash. So why not the historic school buses in the US?
Fortunately for Mr. Hill he was not very fast at the time of impact...

· Smidge204 · 1 year ago

Perhaps worth noting is that according to the good people over at the mynissanleaf forum, the vehicle is now property of the insurance company and is up for auction.

The Nissan LEAF community may end up with some interesting parts to experiment on!

· NeilBlanchard · 1 year ago

Right, and remember the Hummer that rear ended a school bus? It darn near tore the roof off...

http://www.clublexus.com/forums/car-chat/256925-hummer-rear-ends-school-...

Neil

· goldenfooler (not verified) · 1 year ago

While its a loss of a car. I doubt the battery was anywhere near in trouble.

· theflew · 1 year ago

@goldenfooler - I agree if the Leaf would have caught fire that would have been very disturbing given this was nowhere near the Leaf battery.

· alt-e · 1 year ago

What? No mushroom cloud?

· Chris O (not verified) · 1 year ago

Mushroom cloud? No, that would be hydrogen....

All Discussions

Ford Neglects Focus Electric, But It's Still California-Compliant

Ford Focus Electric Article · 15 comments

Jim Motavalli says:
Riding high on hybrids and plug-in hybrids, Ford isn't devoting a lot of time to its Focus Electric, which has sold...

French Train Company Offers Free Electric Car Travel on Auto-Train

Article · 3 comments

Nikki Gordon-Bloomfield says:
This summer, thousands of Americans will pack up their car, cancel the paper, and head out on the open road for a...

When an Electric Vehicle Is More like a Personal Bus, Than a Car

Article · 3 comments

Brad Berman says:
Today’s electric cars can provide all the necessary range, with cheap and easy home recharging, for more than 90...

Prius Plug-in EV Charge

Toyota Prius Plug-in Hybrid Discussion · 14 comments

janespip says:
I have owned my Prius PI for 6 months. I have been told by several authorities that the amount of EV charge...

Eight Rules of Electric Vehicle Charging Etiquette

Article · 1 comment

Brad Berman says:
1EV Spots for EVs It’s absolutely never acceptable for an internal combustion car to park in a spot designated...

Paul Scott Uses DNC Refund To Buy Electric Cars for Relatives

Article · 9 comments

Nikki Gordon-Bloomfield says:
Paul Scott’s public announcement two weeks ago that he was spending $32,400 to talk EVs with President Obama may have...

Eight Factors Determining Total Cost of Ownership of an Electric Car

Article · 1 comment

Brad Berman says:
1Actual Price of Vehicle It’s easy enough to pinpoint the MSRP for a car, but most calculations use the lowest...

The Electric Drive Conference: Report From the Front

Article · 1 comment

Jim Motavalli says:
The Electric Drive Transportation Association has been in the trenches lobbying for EVs since 1989. While it's not yet...

Power Institute Study: Total Cost of Ownership Cheaper for Electric Cars

Article · 17 comments

Nikki Gordon-Bloomfield says:
Assuming identical finance packages and an average gas price of $3.62 per gallon, the Volt proved marginally cheaper to...

Drive Report: Mileage in a Week with the 2013 Toyota Prius Plug-in Hybrid

Toyota Prius Plug-in Hybrid Article · 13 comments

Nikki Gordon-Bloomfield says:
When Toyota unveiled its Prius Plug-in Hybrid in 2011, there was significant consternation in the plug-in car world....