I'm jealous Brad! Great write up. Based on this review, it's such a shame that the Fit will have such limited availability, and that it'll only be available for lease. What kind of wait am I looking at to get one in Colorado -- late 2013, or even into 2014?
First Drive: Honda Fit EV Combines Power and Practicality
Let’s not mince words: the Honda Fit EV kicks ass.
If Honda President Takanobu Ito is looking for a car to bring driving fun to the company’s brand—his main message from the 2011 Tokyo Motor Show—he need look no further than the Fit EV. Last week, I was among the world’s first journalists to drive the compact pure electric car—in two six-minute jaunts around the Twin Ring Montegi grounds north of Tokyo—and was floored by the level of performance delivered by the all-electric Fit. I was just as amused to witness my colleagues on the press tour—made up almost entirely of writers for the horsepower-obsessed auto buff rags—step away from their drives, shaking their heads and picking their jaws off the pavement.
“Wow, this thing scoots,” was the refrain.
The Fit EV has a 94-kilowatt electric motor compared to the Nissan LEAF’s 80-kW motor. But that 17.5 percent boost in power only begins to tell the story about how much quicker the Fit EV is than the LEAF. Honda would not divulge the Fit EV’s curb weight, but the Fit’s dimensions, inside and out, are demonstrably smaller than the LEAF’s. The Fit EV is not a ground-up purpose-built electric; it’s a straight adaptation from the gas-powered Fit, but Honda managed to save all but a slight percentage of passenger and cargo space, lifting the seats by about two inches to make room for the battery pack (while giving up the rear seat’s flip-up theater-style function, which allows easier storage of stuff when nobody’s in the back). If you were going to convert any gasoline car to a sporty electric commuter, the Fit—with its clever packaging of decent space in a small lightweight five-seat format—would be my first choice.
Other electric cars have modes, but what makes the Fit EV unique is how much power is delivered while in Sport mode.
It’s not just the more powerful motor and lighter weight that gives the Fit so much zing. It’s the “Sport” mode. When in “Normal,” the Fit EV offered a drive similar to the LEAF’s standard (not "eco") drive, which is quite fun on city streets. The Sport mode illuminates a red glow in the dashboard and transforms the electric acceleration to exhilaration—obviously not Tesla-Roadster-level. But in terms of feel (if not raw power), it's in the neighborhood of the Mini-E—and with a lot more refinement in its road manners and much more commuter-friendly platform.
The Fit EV leaves all other small electric cars I’ve driven in the dust. The Fit EV is the small electric car that the Think City could have been, if it stretched out and grew up. Compared to the Mitsubishi i, the Fit EV feels much more like a real car—in terms of design, space, and fit and finish—and it makes the i’s performance feel anemic. The Fit EV should make Daimler’s engineers feel downright embarrassed about its slowpoke smart fortwo electric drive.

Of course, putting the Fit EV into Sport mode will suck down the car’s 20 kilowatt-hours of juice—19 of which are usable—faster than the Normal mode. But on most days, I drive less than half of the car’s expected 75- to 80-mile real-world range—and on those days, I would keep the Fit EV in Sport mode (and pray that I don’t rack up too many speeding tickets). On days when I know I have more miles to travel, I would be quite satisfied with the LEAF-like performance of the Fit EV’s Normal mode. The Econ mode would only get used to disengage the regen braking and allow for coasting. I strongly encourage Honda to rename this mode “Coasting” when applied to the Fit EV.
I would challenge any of my petro-hooked colleagues to find a car for $399 a month that combines more head-snapping fun, commuter functionality, and low cost to fuel.
The Fit feels more upright than the LEAF—in part, due to those raised seats—so it’s a smidgen awkward for my 6’4” frame. It certainly is a tighter squeeze in the back for five decent-size human beings, which the LEAF can handle. But otherwise, the car is like the gas-powered Fit. Its ride was solid, the handling nimble, the road noise minimal and the quality on par with anything Honda is producing these days. My driving course had several decent upslopes, which the Fit EV stormed with confidence. The Honda Fit EV's regen braking is unnoticeable in Sport and Normal modes while in the D gear. Drop it into B gear, and the regen grabs hard enough to make the brake foot pedal irrelevant, except for unplanned safety stopping.
The Fit EV comes with a 6.6 kW charger—meaning a relatively speedy charge from empty to full in as little as three hours. The U.S. version will not be available with a DC quick charger.
Unpretentious and direct, the Honda Fit EV's interface provides a clear indication of the battery's state of charge.
The state of charge meter is offered with about 100 hash marks, in essence giving both a graphical and numerical representation of energy in the batteries. That works for me, and is a lot better than the 12 hard-to-decipher illuminated bars found in the LEAF. (There’s also a guessed-at remaining range number, but despite fiddling with modes and AC, I was unable to see it move.)
Restoring Honda's Green Leadership
I had a total of about 12 minutes with the car, but I’m confident that a similar test drive in the Honda Fit EV would close the deal for mainstream commuters with even a slight inclination to go electric. That’s based purely on how normal the car looks and works—for example, it starts with a key not a push-button—and how abnormally fast and silently it drives. Moreover, the Fit EV could also restore Honda’s image as a leader in the green car space—a position lost since the demise of the original Honda Insight hybrid; the quick rise and fall of the ill-conceived Accord Hybrid; the promotion of the going-nowhere fuel-cell FCX Clarity (which I also drive last week); and…(no need to list all the recent mis-steps).
Honda President Takanobu Ito stood by the EV-STER electric car sports concept at the 2011 Tokyo Motor Show, but the car is unlikely to go into production. Yet, the Honda Fit EV could provide nearly as much driving fun, with a lot more practicality.
I predict that, if the production version of the Fit EV coming out next year maintains the same level of acceleration as the one I drove, the car’s 1,100 lease holders (and the automotive press) are going to sing-shout its praises—not for its green-ness, but for the pure fun it delivers. There will be a cry for Honda to build a lot more than 1,100 units—and as soon as possible.
Mr. Ito: Don’t wait for that response, when the car goes on lease next year. Start right now to line up more production capacity, the necessary supplier relationships, and marketing campaigns. You have a winner on your hands.
Comments
· Christof Demont... · 23 weeks ago
· alt-e · 23 weeks ago
This article and others on Honda recently show how important the leadership of a company is in determining its future (or lack there of). Here Honda's engineers have develped a great product with the potential of keeping right up there with Nissan. But instead the leadership chooses not to use it and potenially begins Honda's decline. It will be a future case study in MBA classes.
· Brett Owen (not verified) · 23 weeks ago
I wonder if you could take the usual Honda Civic modding route and stick in a custom electric motor to get it to go even faster. That would be kind of neat. It looks cool though. I was originally waiting to get this car instead of a Leaf just because I like Honda, or did. If they ever 'sell' it I'll get it, otherwise back to the Leaf. :)
· Ken Fry · 23 weeks ago
Hi Brad -- great writeup!
alt-e: I hope they pay heed. I have three Hondas in my household, have won races on them, worked in a Honda motorcycle dealership etc. But lately, they seem to be loosing their touch. Committing to bringing this out in volume would be a good first step back.
For me (and I think many) this would be more appealing than the Leaf... but I can't get one.
· NeilBlanchard · 23 weeks ago
Wow -- that is great to hear! I sure hope they hear the applause and built 10,000+ of these in the first year. The Fit package is great to start with -- my brother drives one (he's 6'-6"+) and the performance and range are just what most people will want.
Build a *bunch* of them Honda -- please! And sell them to us.
Neil
· EVNow · 23 weeks ago
Sigh ... building 1,000 requires totally different production / procurement strategies compared to building 10,000.
What EV movement needs is committed volume production by a couple more OEMs.
· regman · 23 weeks ago
Brad, Did you have a chance to do a good evaluation of coasting mode?
· Pipeline · 23 weeks ago
Ass kicker! I love it.
Finally! A more reasonably priced EV we can fly in. A conversion done right. This is what I've wanted since I started driving. Fast, fun driving, without the (profound) regrets of purchasing of gas. Looking forward to learning more and thanks for the excellent report.
As a (previous) Honda owner, I wholly support Brad's call to Mr. Ito.
· gascant (not verified) · 23 weeks ago
Lease? If you're right about how it drives, I suspect that no one will want to give up their Fit EV when the lease runs out. Did Honda offer anything on a buyout program? We bought our LEAF because we wanted to keep it.
It does have a rather Robot-ish back end, don't you think?
· JRP3 · 23 weeks ago
Sounds great, but limited production and lease only is a total fail. Especially with the Toshiba Scib batteries that have a 5000 cycle potential, I want to OWN that vehicle, not lease it.
· EVNow · 23 weeks ago
@JRP3 · "Sounds great, but limited production and lease only is a total fail. "
You missed the other major fail - only in CA.
· alt-e · 23 weeks ago
Other than the things you just mentioned, on option to buy or an option to lease the new version, there might also be the option to renew the lease. Maybe at a lower monthly rate for the second lease period.
· Spies (not verified) · 23 weeks ago
Honda was kind enough to renew the lease on our EV Plus for a couple of years after the initial 3 years were up and at a lower rate. We got very close to having it for a total of 6 years when we got the letter they wanted the vehicle back. I suspect it was shredded not long after. We are not going through that again so until Honda has an EV for sale we are not interested. We are enjoying out Nissan Leaf however.
· JRP3 · 23 weeks ago
Ask Honda what message they think they are sending with lease only when other car makers are selling EV's. Do they not have faith in their product? Is this another experiment? Remind them of the bad taste left after they crushed perfectly good EV's the last time.
· EVNow · 23 weeks ago
@Brad Berman · "What should I propose to Honda--to legitimately earn the trust of the EV community?"
What is the end goal here for Honda ?
BMW did something similar - leasing Mini-Es. Most of us thought it was just a CARB play. But by making real investments in Electric line of vehicles (i3 etc) BMW has convinced EV sceptics that they are serious.
What does Honda really plan to do ? Are they planning to make substantial investments in real EVs ?
· alt-e · 23 weeks ago
I would hope that the end goal is to continue a dialog with Honda so that they can come to understand that there is a market for their EVs out there and that any steps they take to move to higher volume and to sell their EVs instead of leasing them will be met very positively.
I have had discussions with the development people at Honda in the past (but not with the corporate leadership) and I can tell you that they like to really think things through and make logical desicions. They are not into copying other company strategies but like to come up with their own.
So if they are given the information that there is a big and supportive market out there for as many EVs as they can produce and if they know that the EV community really likes the Fit EV and if they can come to understand that they will fall behind other car companies and loose their edge in the car business if they don't participate in high volume EV production now, then maybe they will change their position. I have seen them change positions in the past after internal reflection. They are a concensis decision making company so it can just take a while.
· KeiJidosha · 23 weeks ago
@ EVNow - CARB credit is probably part of the justification, and financially helps get the R&D funds and green light for an EV project with profit margins three generations away. Regards the lease only, if the Fit EV turns out to be a hit, it may eventually see sales or renewals. I think the MINI E surprised BMW by being so reliable. The MINI E fleet keeps getting repurposed, and is now headed to the 2012 Summer Olympics in London. Fit EV’s drive is in-house, so may be practical for longer term support. Honda needs to get on the field to learn what role EVs have in their future. Step one is to build the car and put it in customers hands.
· EVNow · 23 weeks ago
@alt-e · "So if they are given the information that there is a big and supportive market out there for as many EVs as they can produce..."
Actually I don't think there is a large market for EVs now. Question is - will Honda develop the EV market or just get there once it is created by others like Nissan.
· alt-e · 23 weeks ago
@EVNow - There is plenty of EV market out there. Right now. EVs today, with current battery technology, are not the primary cars for most households. But they do make perfectly fine second cars in a country where nearly everyone gets nearly everywhere by car. There are therefore at least 2 cars in most households. Battery capacity today can do this second car.
Say Honda were to make one full car model worth of EVs per year. That would be around 100,000 cars per year. That sounds like a lot of cars and it is in absolute terms, but it is only a fraction of the new cars sold each year. There are somewhere around 16 million new cars sold in the US alone each year. Say 5 of the most forward looking car companies did one full car model as an EV. That would be 500,000 per year or around 3% of all new cars. That leaves 97% of all new cars to be ICE.
So is 3% of the population ready for EVs? I think so. There are so many people that are so upset with so many things that EVs are the answer to. I think it is underestimating the current population to say there are not 3% of new car buyers that are ready to make some sacrifices in range to do it.
I know that some will point to how long it took for the Prius to get to where it is. But keep in mind that each of these EVs will be a different design for a different demographic. Now that the Prius will have 3 variations they will probably sell a lot more. And EVs deliver much more of a break from oil then the Prius does. Especially in terms of sending the kind of message a lot of people want to send.
Plus EVs are seen as cool by the younger generation in a way that the Prius does not. It is true that younger people have less money for new cars, but there are still some out there who buy them. And we are talking about only 3%.
And what about the lack of charger infrastructure? It isn't needed for that 2nd car in the household.
· Jose G · 23 weeks ago
@alt-e
"EVs today, with current battery technology, are not the primary cars for most households."
I actually call the Leaf my primary car. I drive it every day, 50 miles / day (at least 75% of my driving). My secondary car is the old gas car that I use for occasional road trips.
· alt-e · 23 weeks ago
As new and better batteries are developed, as we build a charger infrastructure for people on trips, as people see how much better the EV driving experience is, as car designers do new and interesting things with EV designs, we will see the 97% and the 3% flip.
It is to protect itself against that time that Honda needs to leap in there and get some experience with a mass produced EV. Not just experience designing them, but experience all up and down their operations. Engineering, maintenance, parts logistics, sales, the whole bit.
· alt-e · 23 weeks ago
@Jose G - I am just trying to talk about the majority of the population in terms that are, if anything, being negative on EVs to show that yes, there is a demand right now.
· EVNow · 23 weeks ago
@alt-e · "There is plenty of EV market out there."
Like Jose above, my primary car is Leaf.
But no, there isn't that big a market today. The "potential" market is huge. 60% of Americans have multiple cars - and thus can replace one with an EV. But that is only a potential market - it will take a long time, lot of effort & money to develop that market. You need commitment from OEMs to do that - Honda lacks that commitment.
There isn't an easy market that in 10s of thusands per month that will just materialize if only OEMs build cars. The market needs to be developed. They have to advertise, figure out how to train the sales peoples, be committed to investing a lot of money now for returns 5 years from now.
· JRP3 · 23 weeks ago
Not to mention that Nissan LEAF's seem to be selling as fast as they can be produced. I'd say there is a strong market chomping at the bit to get their hands on an EV.
· alt-e · 23 weeks ago
@EVNow - Of course they will have to advertise, etc., just like they would need to do on any brand new car model. Probably more because it is more new. The whole point of having a dialog with Honda is to nudge them to turn around and get committed to EVs.
Honda is clearly not now committed to EVs but that doesn't mean they cannot be in the future. For us to encourage them to go in that direction can only be a good thing to do.
The worst thing that can happen is that it doesn't work.
· ex-EV1 driver · 22 weeks ago
@alt-e
"For us to encourage them to go in that direction can only be a good thing to do.
I respectfully disagree.
I'd rather people spend their hard earned money supporting companies who are committed to EVs rather paying money to greenwashers like Honda, Ford, BMW, Daimler, Volvo, etc. Money to them is just wasted when it takes money that could go to companies such as Nissan, Tesla, and (hesitatingly) GM who are truly committed.
Dialog is probably good but I'll stop there.
· brg2290 · 22 weeks ago
"ex-EV1 driver ·
I'd rather people spend their hard earned money supporting companies who are committed to EVs rather paying money to greenwashers like Honda, Ford, BMW, Daimler, Volvo, etc."
What's your beef with BMW? It seems to me that they are building an infrastructure that shows a commitment to EV's. This came from an article about the opening of the BMW carbon fiber plant in Moses Lake, WA.
"Standing near the carbon fiber passenger compartment of BMW’s planned i3 vehicle, BMW chairman Norbert Reithofer told a crowd of 150 at the new Moses Lake factory on Thursday morning that carbon fiber will be key for the evolution of electric vehicle.
“The BMW Group is pioneering new frontiers in auto production,” Reithofer said. “Passenger cells are made from carbon fiber to compensate for the greater weight of batteries. Using carbon fiber on this scale has never been attempted before.”
Link to full article here: http://www.bizjournals.com/seattle/news/2011/09/01/bmw-opens-new-moses-l...
· EVNow · 22 weeks ago
@alt-e · "The whole point of having a dialog with Honda is to nudge them to turn around and get committed to EVs."
True - but not based on false premises. There isn't a large market now and won't exist for sometime to come. Just see how Volt is no longer demand constrained and yet selling just over a 1,000 a month.
No doubt the road is hard and difficult (otherwise OEMs would be willingly producing large number of EVs by now). We should keep talking about the inevitability of EVs & the large potential market.
· EVNow · 22 weeks ago
@JRP3 · "Not to mention that Nissan LEAF's seem to be selling as fast as they can be produced. I'd say there is a strong market chomping at the bit to get their hands on an EV."
Depends on what you mean by strong market.
I don't think Nissan can sell more than 4K Leafs a month - after Smyrna opens - at the current specs & price. I'd call that a niche market.
· EVNow · 22 weeks ago
@Brad Berman ·
As you know, GM has been talking about how Volt is supply constrained for a few months now. But every month we see the inventory go up - and so is the Days Supply. Now it is at some 130 days.
Two months back there was an article here about a GM exec saying some 4K Volts would be available for sale. Yet only a thousand got sold in Oct. Same thing in Nov. Looks like more than 12K Volts have been produced - but only 6K sales. Even if 3K are demos & in transit, that still leaves 3K of them on dealer lots. I'll write a post on that one of these days (I didn't do it because I didn't want to "pile on" the troubles Volt is already having).
One possibility is that in CA people are waiting for HOV access Volts. So, in a couple of months when we start seeing such Volts getting delivered, the sale may go up.
Regarding Leaf, there was definitely some difficulty in selling all the MY11 "orphans" that some dealers got hold of in CA. Interestingly, I also saw an Orphan sell for $5K premium at my nearest dealer. Ofcourse, we won't know the real demand until one can walk into a dealership, select the Leaf with the trim & color of choice and drive it home. That will happen only after Smyrna goes online.
It is nice to hear that Accord PHEV (and Fit EV) are well engineered and polished vehicles. But, I do think Honda execs are "uninspired" to put it mildly. They haven't been able to plug the market share bleed overall. They have yielded #2 position in Japan to Nissan and # 2 & #3 Foreign OEM in US to Nissan & Hyundai. When you are the market leader, you can play it safe and conservative like Toyota is doing. But when you are slipping, you can't be conservative. When are they going to wake up ?
· JRP3 · 22 weeks ago
I think part of the Volt problem is that most people who want an EV want an EV and know that the Volt is not one. As for the LEAF maybe there is some saturation in CA but since it's not even available in most states I'd think there is a pretty good unmet demand out there, and nothing available to fill it.
· Ken Fry · 22 weeks ago
Hi Brad,
>> In Tokyo, I was able to drive the Accord-sized plug-in hybrid as well. I'm planning to write that up in the next few days. <<
How cool is that?!! Looking forward to the writeup.
The silent engine in the Accord is a defect. No problem telling when the engine is running in my Zing! (It's an engineered-in feature encouraging the owner to shut the darn thing off.) The engine has saved my butt several times, but it reminds me too much of the engine on a sailboat -- it's nicer when its not running.
· Brian Schwerdt · 22 weeks ago
@Ken Fry - "it reminds me too much of the engine on a sailboat -- it's nicer when its not running."
I had to smile at this comment - that's exactly why I bought an electric motor for my sailboat ;-)
· gascant (not verified) · 22 weeks ago
If the door is open even a crack at Honda, we should stick our collective foot in it. We can't be constrained by the past. They need to hear that people want to buy their EV's (not lease them). They need to see that there is a global market for EVs. Nissan has already proven it--they have changed the lives of thousands of us in the first year.
· alt-e · 22 weeks ago
@ Gascant - That is the spirit. Car companies do listen. It is just that there are forces and constraints that sometimes push the other way. That just means we need to push harder. Now that Nissan has jumped in the game has changed a lot more in our favor. So we stand a better chance then in the EV1 days.
· Jerry (not verified) · 22 weeks ago
Conflicting info on lease vs. buy. MotorTrend says "Initially it will be sold in select California and Oregon, before expanding to six East Coast markets in early 2013...
$36,625 (before tax credits) " http://www.motortrend.com/roadtests/alternative/1112_2013_honda_fit_ev_d...
Add comment
All Discussions
Does EV Quick-Charging By the Minute Make Sense?
Nissan LEAF Article · 2 comments
Brad Berman says:
When drivers of gas-powered cars fill up at the gas station, they know they are paying a certain price for a clear and...
In Veiled Sales Pitch, A123 Warns about Dangers of EV Quick Charging
Article · 14 comments
Brad Berman says:
Last week, battery manufacturer A123 Systems explained in its corporate blog that some lithium-ion batteries are not...
The Race to Lock Down Electric Car Charging Real Estate
Article · 15 comments
Brad Berman says:
How do you know that electric car charging is hitting the mainstream? Because high-profile places like Walgreens and...
Chasing an Elusive Next Generation Battery to Rival Gasoline in Energy Density
Blog Post · 13 comments
Nick Chambers says:
According to a researcher working on I.B.M.'s Battery 500 project, lithium-ion technology has been stagnant since 2003...
Real Electric Car Battery Costs Remain Elusive
Article · 24 comments
Brad Berman says:
Recent reports about the declining cost of electric car batteries raise as many questions as they answer. I suspect...
Cars.com Lists Chevy Volt as One of "Top 10 Under-Appreciated Cars and Trucks"
Chevy Volt Article · 11 comments
Eric Loveday says:
Though the Chevy Volt is no stranger to awards and accolades, this latest honor seems fitting, if a bit unexpected....
Toyota Prius Plug-In Hybrid is Third Quickest Selling Vehicle in US
Toyota Prius Plug-in Hybrid Article · 6 comments
Eric Loveday says:
April's third quickest selling vehicle in the US was the 2012 Toyota Prius Plug-in Hybrid. The Prius with a plug spent...
Ford Focus Electric Rollout Continues to Crawl
Ford Focus Electric Article · 16 comments
Brad Berman says:
I ran into a friend in Los Angeles this week who called Ford’s dealership in Santa Monica—a red hot hotspot for EV...
What is the True Range of an Electric Car? The Mini E Experience Leaves Many Questions
Mini E Blog Post · 32 comments
Nick Chambers says:
Current electric car range estimates in the U.S. are based on an EPA test cycle that doesn't truly reflect real-world...
Tesla Model S Range Exceeds Even Tesla's Expecations
Tesla Model S Article · 6 comments
Eric Loveday says:
According to Tesla Motors, the 85-kWh version of the Model S is expected to achieve 250-350 miles of range during...
Great stuff! We need more cars that burn rubber, not gasoline. I'm not keen on a lease-only option for the Fit EV ... the tuners need to get their hands on these little beasts.
Head-Snapping or Neck-Snapping, that is the question ... :)