Earthquake, Electric Car Delays and What Really Matters

By Chelsea Sexton · March 21, 2011

Plugging Chevy Volt

The earthquake and tsunami in Japan might delay delivery of some Nissan LEAFs, but should be put in perspective of the human and global economic impact of the catastrophe.

Note from Brad Berman, PluginCars.com Editor: The volume of exciting electric car news is accelerating. Some of the headlines are very encouraging, but other stories—getting just as much play—are not much more than EV buzz for buzz sake. So, I asked Chelsea to help us sort out the wheat from the chaff by pointing out a handful of stories that deserve some attention. Take it away, Chelsea...

1

It’s inevitable news and to no one's surprise: The recent earthquake and aftermath in Japan is reverberating throughout the auto industry, including various plug-in car programs. The full effects are still being assessed, but Nissan last week had to halt production of several production plants, including that which builds the Leaf. But then news came over the weekend that Nissan will restart production at five of six plants, including Oppama where LEAF is produced. Other reports said it was “partly operational.”

It is unclear whether or not the Chevrolet Volt will be affected, but it's possible that supply of the Japanese-built transmission may be stalled.

Other programs have yet to publicly specify if and how they're impacted, but it's safe to assume that most will be, to varying degrees. The Japanese built Mitsubishi i is the next likely candidate, but in a global industry, damage to smaller suppliers will still have an effect up the chain of American and European cars.

Of course, this both matters and doesn't in the grand scheme. I admit to having been horrified to see a few people's first reaction to the quake be "but what will this do to my LEAF delivery timing?" At the same time, there is no separating this industry from the overall economic recovery that must now happen.

2

Shouldn't be news: Lots of folks have been spun up this week over the fact that a marketing study "discovered" that consumers are confused by hybrid and plug-in technology, even after ten years of hybrids having been available. Broadly speaking, they don't know that hybrids use both electricity and gas, that they have batteries on board, or that plug-in hybrids can run on battery power alone (though it remains to be seen how much they do as a class.) After all the backhanded "you don't have to plug it in" advertising done by Honda and Toyota over the years, I'm not surprised people don't fully comprehend the role of electricity in a hybrid. But really, who cares that they don't? Sure, I've had my share of Prius drivers insist that they drive electric cars, but how many gas car owners do you know that could explain specifically how they operate either?

Yes, we need more consumer education, including in the different "flavors" of electrified vehicles. But we also need to have some perspective. This is not news. And when it comes to marketing, mainstream consumers care much more about what a car does than how it does it.

2

Quick Hits

  • Dubious news: BYD followed up last week's Wikileaks news with intentions to launch in the US in late 2011. I know Brad was reasonably impressed with his test drive, but I can't help but feel skeptical about this one for now.
  • Just for fun: I'm curious to see how it moves from concept to production, but the Fido scooter looks rather promising.
  • At long last: Revenge of the Electric Car has a premiere date!

About the author

Chelsea Sexton is a veteran clean transportation and energy advocate; her work on General Motors’ EV1 program was featured in the Sony Pictures Classics film, “Who Killed the Electric Car?” She continues her work as the Founder of the Lightning Rod Foundation, and has led the creation of the Automotive X PRIZE, and is a co-founder of Plug In America, the largest consumer-oriented electric ...

Full bio · 59 posts

Comments

· darelldd · 48 weeks ago

Good point on the "how it works" bit. It would be interesting to discover just what percentage of today's drivers know how an internal combustion engine works.... and how that combustion can produce over 20 pounds of C02 from one gallon of gasoline! And not knowing all that hasn't stopped people from buying gas cars, certainly. Makes you go, "hmmm."

- Darell, EVnut

· Tom Moloughney · 48 weeks ago

Chels: I think I'd describe my feelings as disappointed rather than horrified to hear how some people's first reaction was to ask how this will effect the delivery of their LEAF.

Two things to consider:
First, the "how does this directly impact me" mindset is prevalent in many minds. My restaurant is about 12 miles from NYC and we watched the towers fall from the hill behind the building. I remember the next day someone calling me to ask if the food for party they booked in two weeks would still be made or if they needed to find another caterer.
Second, Nissan has botched the initial delivery process and people are waiting much longer than they initially thought they would have to. The communication has been very poor and some folks really have no idea when they'll be getting their car. If this tragedy is going to add another 3 or 4 months to their wait than maybe they need to find an alternative or temporary solution.

Mind you, I am not making any excuses for anyone that looks past the tragedy and suffering going on in Japan to wonder about their own "inconvenience". I'm just not horrified by it, I'm disappointed.

As for the confusion, adding the term EREV to the mix didn't help any!

· Brad Berman · 48 weeks ago

Darell - When you consider "full fuel cycle," the numbers grows beyond 25 pounds of CO2 per gallon. Agreed that it's hard to get most important messages through--in a way that is truly relevant to consumers. Which brings in Tom's point about "direct impact to me."

Maybe it's time to get the PluginCars.com community to start working on a Plug-in Manifesto (wiki style) to develop the messages and key points that would really mean something to people? Worth experimenting with this?

www.plugincars.com/manifesto
(You need to be a registered logged in user to add comment).

· JJJJJJ (not verified) · 48 weeks ago

1) The dangers of putting all your manufacturing eggs in one regional basket. This goes for all industries, especially those who outsource everything to China. If China gets hit with a disaster (natural or political) most US companies are 100% screwed. Nike, Apple, Dell etc....

Car manufacturers and other industries would be smarter to follow the approach of companies like VW, which have factories in China, for China, in Brazil, for Brazil, in Germany, for Germany etc.

2) I understand the confusion, especially with the volt. It's a hybrid, but not THAT hybrid. They really should have picked a different name.

· Yegor · 48 weeks ago

"Toyota Motor said Tuesday that it is extending a halt on full vehicle production in Japan through March 26 as it and other major manufacturers try to recover from the effects of this month's earthquake.

Meanwhile, three of Nissan's four Japanese plants were up and running again Monday, although their capabilities were limited to producing auto parts. Nissan plans to resume full vehicle production on Wednesday."

http://money.cnn.com/2011/03/22/news/international/japan_manufacturing/i...

· EVNow · 48 weeks ago

'I admit to having been horrified to see a few people's first reaction to the quake be "but what will this do to my LEAF delivery timing?" '

Yes, but a small minority.

http://www.mynissanleaf.com/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=2965

Also statements like "Screw the car and deliveries. I hope that people are OK."

· Chelsea Sexton · 48 weeks ago

Yes, a minority. As with other things, it's the anomalies that stick out the most.

Add comment

·

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

All Discussions

Presidential Politics, Rising Gas Prices and Electric Cars

Article · 27 comments

Brad Berman says:
The biggest factor affecting electric car sales is the price at the pump. And it’s on the rise. The national average...

How Much Will Electric Vehicle Buyers Pay for Additional Range?

Tesla Model S Article · 8 comments

Eric Loveday says:
Range costs money, right? Now, with the looming launch of the Tesla Model S and its numerous range variations, Tesla...

Maps & Apps: How to Find Charging Stations in the Wild

Article · 22 comments

Patrick Connor says:
Many modern EVs such as the Nissan LEAF come with telematics systems that include charging station data. This is the...

Chinese Vehicle Makers Arrive, With Electric Cars Not Far Behind

Article · 1 comment

Laurent J. Masson says:
The auto industry has long feared the arrival of a Chinese electric car that would be vastly cheaper than anything...

Nissan LEAF Now Available in Seven More States

Nissan LEAF Article · 9 comments

Eric Loveday says:
Nissan officially began taking orders yesterday for its 2012 LEAF from residents of Delaware, Indiana, Louisiana,...

Think Quietly Sets Price of City Electric Car at $41,695 (Update)

Think City Article · 44 comments

Brad Berman says:
In November, I received word from Think’s top marketing executive that the price of the Think City two-seat electric...

The Challenge for Plug-In Cars

Chevy Volt Blog Post · 49 comments

Michael Coates says:
Plug-in cars are going to face a serious challenge in the marketplace during the coming decade--not from naysayers or...

Chevy Volt MSRP is $41,000, But Will Lease For Same Price as Nissan LEAF

Chevy Volt Blog Post · 8 comments

Nick Chambers says:
GM used the stage at Plugin 2010 this morning to let the long-awaited cat out of the bag: the Chevrolet Volt will start...

Best Buy to Provide Ford Focus Electric Charging Stations At Lower Prices Than Competition

Ford Focus Electric Article · 35 comments

Nick Chambers says:
Highlighting their increasing push into selling electric car accessories—and supporting their nationwide rollout—Best...

Plug-in Hybrid Volkswagen Golf Expected in 2015

Article · 6 comments

Eric Loveday says:
The next-generation Volkswagen Golf will feature a slew of powertrain options, including a plug-in hybrid version that...